Issue #3: ChatGPT tests 5 links above its answers

The AI SEO Digest by ASAD, with founder Shantanu Pandey

ChatGPT is testing 5 plain links above its answers, for logged out users only. Plus: the November core update collides with Black Friday, Ziff Davis says it is not planning on a search recovery, Google tests removing the AI Mode tab, and open web traffic is down 12.2% from its 2022 peak. Five real tests and Google updates, curated for AI SEO.

Welcome to Issue #3

Welcome to the third issue of The AI SEO Digest.

This week, the clearest lesson is that the front door to the web is moving. ChatGPT is testing links above its answers, and Google is testing fewer doors into AI Mode, in the same week a core update is still rolling out.

Here are the 5 most important AI SEO updates from the last few days. We have put real tests first.

Brought to you by ASAD

The AI SEO Digest is curated by ASAD, the AI SEO agency.

We help brands get cited in ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Claude, and Gemini. We also work on technical SEO, content strategy, and digital PR.

1. ChatGPT is testing 5 links above its answers

Screenshot of a ChatGPT answer with a block of 5 web links shown above the AI generated answer
Screenshot: Joe Youngblood.

Joe Youngblood found ChatGPT testing a block of 5 plain links above its AI answer. The catch is that the links only appear when the user is logged out.

In his testing, the block showed up in 90% of scenarios, whether the user typed keywords or a full question. It always sat above the answer, even for local queries, where it appeared above the map and the local business listings.

The test covered every major metro he serves, including Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, Kansas City, Nashville, and Los Angeles. It also covered local, ecommerce, SaaS, B2B, software, travel, and recipe queries.

The links were not limited to one kind of page. Youngblood saw blog posts, listicles, YouTube videos, service pages, Reddit posts, Facebook posts and videos, and even products.

OpenAI has not confirmed the test, so it may not stick. But it landed the same week OpenAI launched its Business Hub, which suggests OpenAI is softening toward the open web as it prepares for an IPO.

Why it matters:

If this ships, ChatGPT stops being a dead end for publishers. Ranking in ChatGPT could start sending clicks again, for the first time since AI answers arrived in 2022.

👉 Read more about the ChatGPT links test

2. The November core update is rolling out, and it collides with Black Friday

Timeline showing the November core update began on 10 November, may run to about 24 November, and the first clean comparison week falls after Black Friday
Timeline from Google Search Status Dashboard and Search Engine Journal reporting. Credit: Search Engine Journal.

Google started rolling out the November 2026 core update on 10 November. It is the third core update of the year, it applies globally and to all languages, and Google says it may take up to 2 weeks to complete.

As of 12 November, the update was still in progress, and no completion notice had appeared by the morning of 16 November. That means ranking movement this week is still mid rollout, not a final result.

Google advises waiting at least a full week after a core update finishes before comparing Search Console data. On the current timetable, that first clean comparison week includes Thanksgiving, Black Friday on 27 November, and Cyber Monday on 30 November.

So retailers comparing that week with a normal week will be comparing holiday traffic with everyday traffic. Log the rollout dates now, and judge the update on the weeks after the holidays instead.

One more wrinkle: Google confirmed a logging error cut impressions in the Search Console generative AI report for data from 9 to 11 November. It affected data logging only, not real performance, but those three days are a gap in your reports, not a trend.

Why it matters:

Any ranking read taken during this rollout, or the week after it, is contaminated twice over, by the update and by the holidays. Annotate 10 November and 12 November in your tracking, plus the 9 to 11 November data gap, and wait for a clean week.

👉 Read more about the November core update

3. Ziff Davis says it is not planning on a search recovery

Bar chart showing about 2.7 billion AI Overview and AI Mode impressions and about 0.27 billion Google Search clicks for Ziff Davis properties in the quarter, with the clicks figure derived from the reported nearly 10 times ratio
Chart from Ziff Davis earnings call data, via Search Engine Journal. Credit: Search Engine Journal.

Ziff Davis chief executive Vivek Shah told investors on the third quarter earnings call that organic Google referrals to its properties fell about 37% year over year. He added that the company is not planning on a search recovery.

Shah also put about 2.7 billion AI Overview and AI Mode impressions in Search Console for the quarter at nearly 10 times the clicks those same sites received from Google Search. That gap is the clearest publisher number yet for how much AI visibility now outweighs AI clicks.

Tripadvisor told a similar story on its own call. Its chief financial officer Mike Noonan said SEO will still be a headwind to growth in 2027, and the company recorded a $369.5 million goodwill impairment largely attributed to traffic headwinds from changes in the search landscape.

Tripadvisor also said marketing rose to 48.8% of revenue, up from 43.3% a year earlier, as it shifts spend from free search traffic to paid channels.

One caution on the Ziff Davis comparison: it is not a click through rate. Search Console counts clicks on AI features inside the overall click total, so impressions and clicks are not measured on the same basis.

Why it matters:

Two large publishers are now budgeting as if free search traffic does not come back. If your plan still assumes a recovery, it is betting against the companies living through the same shift.

👉 Read more about the Ziff Davis and Tripadvisor earnings calls

4. Google is testing removing the AI Mode tab

Screenshot of a Google search results page with no AI Mode tab in the tab bar
Screenshot: Search Engine Roundtable, from Glenn Gabe on X.

Google is testing removing AI Mode from the search tab bar, and removing the Ask anything follow up box from under AI Overviews. The test was spotted by Glenn Gabe, who shared screenshots of both changes.

Barry Schwartz at Search Engine Roundtable could not replicate the test himself. It follows earlier reports of AI Mode buttons disappearing from the Google homepage, and from the search bar for some users.

Chris Long suggested the change may mean AI Mode is no longer a separate experience at all. Google has made no statement, so for now this is a test, not a rollout.

The test appeared the same week Google announced new app connections for AI Mode. If fewer doors lead into AI Mode, fewer AI Overview readers will continue into a follow up conversation, which is a distribution cut, not a shutdown.

Why it matters:

AI Mode citations only help if people reach AI Mode. Watch whether this test ships, because it decides how much traffic the AI Mode surface can send you at all.

👉 Read more about the AI Mode tab test

5. Open web traffic is down 12.2% from its 2022 peak

Chart showing total visits to the top million websites falling while estimated internet users rise from 2021 to 2026
Chart: SparkToro, data from Similarweb and DataReportal.

Visits to the world’s top million websites peaked in the first quarter of 2022 at 2.243 trillion. By the third quarter of 2026, they stood at 1.970 trillion, down 12.2% from the peak.

The low point was the first quarter of 2026, at 1.914 trillion visits, down 14.7%. The figures come from Similarweb browser data, shared by SparkToro, and they cover desktop and mobile browser visits only, not app use.

Over the same period, estimated internet users grew from 4.95 billion to 6.15 billion, up about 24%. Visits per user therefore fell 29.2%, though that figure rests on user estimates that were revised in 2025 for India and China, so treat it with care.

The surprise is where the loss sits. The top 100 sites took only about 3 points more share, from about 33% to about 36%, so the decline is spread across the web rather than hoarded by Big Tech. Fishkin calls stagnation a more accurate description than consolidation.

Fishkin gave no reasons for the decline. His candidate factors include app only use, AI tools, social platforms, and behaviour change after Covid.

Why it matters:

This is the long view behind this issue. The open web is getting fewer browser visits even as more people come online, so AI visibility is now a fight for a shrinking pool of visits, not just a new channel on top of the old one.

👉 Read more about open web traffic falling 12.2%

From the ASAD blog

We tested which websites ChatGPT cites most for brand reviews, across 30 mid market brands.

Chart from the ASAD study showing BBB with 21 citation appearances and Trustpilot in 18 of 30 brand answers
Chart from the ASAD study. Image: ASAD.

Our team ran one “[Brand] reviews” query per brand in ChatGPT, signed out, in a fresh chat, for 30 mid market brands: 10 SaaS, 10 ecommerce, and 10 service businesses. All 30 checks were completed on 21 October 2026.

BBB recorded the most citation appearances, with 21, but Trustpilot appeared in more brand answers, 18 of 30 against 12 for BBB. Totals alone mislead, so track appearances and brand coverage separately.

Citation sources are category specific. G2 and Capterra led for SaaS, with 6 and 5 appearances, while BBB and Reddit tied at 10 each for ecommerce, and BBB led services with 11. Pick review platforms by industry fit, not overall totals.

ChatGPT sometimes cited the wrong entity altogether. A “Tenet reviews” query returned sources about the 2020 film Tenet, not the agency, while “Teamwork” and “Diggs” produced clarification questions and zero sources. Verify ChatGPT identified the right business before counting any citation.

Finally, check the exact pages cited, not just the domain. BBB links led to profiles, customer reviews, and complaint pages, while Reddit links pointed at real product experience threads about price, sizing, and delivery delays. A citation is not an endorsement, and a complaint page counts the same as a review page in a raw count.

👉 Read more about which websites ChatGPT cites for brand reviews

One tactic for this week

Pick your brand plus 3 competitors, and run a “[Brand] reviews” query for each in ChatGPT while signed out. Note two things for each: whether ChatGPT names the right business, and which review platforms it cites.

Then fix one gap this week. Correct one inaccurate profile on the platform ChatGPT cites most for your category, or add one page of real proof, like a customer quote or a link to your docs, behind a claim the AI states without evidence.

While you are there, run one buying prompt in ChatGPT while logged out, and check whether the 5 link block appears and whether your site is in it. Log 10 November and 12 November in your tracking sheet, and annotate the 9 to 11 November Search Console gap, so your November reads stay honest.


What ASAD does, and how our approach is different

ASAD is the AI SEO agency behind this newsletter. We help brands get seen, cited, and chosen in ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Claude, and Gemini.

Most SEO still optimises for rankings and clicks. That is not enough anymore, because people now get their answer inside the AI chat and may never click at all.

Our approach starts with AI visibility, not just rankings. We check where your brand appears in AI answers, where it is missing, and what the AI is getting wrong about you.

Then we fix the foundations that decide those answers. That means technical SEO, clear content the AI can retrieve and cite, and digital PR that builds trust in the sources AI models use.

We test across models and prompts, not just one tool. Because as this issue shows, the same question can give a different winner in every model.

The result is simple to measure. More mentions, more citations, and more people choosing your brand inside AI search, not just more traffic.

Get your ASAD AI Visibility Report

Want to know where your brand stands in AI search?

Get your free ASAD AI Visibility Report. We check whether ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews mention and cite your brand. And we show you what to fix first.

Request yours at asad.ae